Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leo Abstract's avatar

Two comments (kept brief in honor of you being sick).

First, there's a new-ish school of therapy (though not yet of psychology) that explores the consultant being a whole team of consultants and offers tools on how to talk to them. It's called Internal Family Systems Therapy.

Second, I read your piece at the Atlantic and would like to make another plug for Nassim Nicholas Taleb's 'Grandmother Principle', which states that we should treat seriously only those studies in social sciences that replicate your grandmother's common sense suggestions on how to live. (I hasten to add that Taleb is old and from Lebanon, so his grandmother likely had levels of common sense wisdom only accessible to our great-great grandmothers.)

Expand full comment
Allison Gregory's avatar

This analogy of the CEO/consultant in the brain reminds me of a point Robert Wright made in his book "Why Buddhism is True." He is talking about the modular view of the brain, particularly our conscious mind.

To summarize, Wright basically says "The modules aren’t like employees in a company. There is no CEO. Modules don’t utilize obedience or harmony. However, they do sometimes collaborate, yet they also sometimes compete with one another. Maybe the most accurate comparison for our conscious mind would be not the president/CEO but the Speaker of the House. The Speaker of the House presides over votes and announces the outcome, yet doesn’t control the votes. Although the Speaker of the House does do some behind-the-scenes nudging of influence to the votes. We can’t rule out that the conscious mind gets to do some nudging here and there."

Hope you're coming up for air and sunshine in that basement!

Expand full comment
28 more comments...

No posts